American Idol Liveblogging--UPDATED

Do Neil Diamond's songs not translate well? Simon was right about the first five. Ew to all of them.

Jason Castro's soulful eyes cannot overcome his sucky, sappy vocals. Bleh.

David Cook. First, who does his hair because so splattered on the side of his head it's distracting. But he does a great job with this song. He's a rock star. Period.

Brooke needs to go. I'm sick of her. She has pretty blond hair and blue eyes that look they'll cry all the time.

David Archuleta--Blech! And everyone loved him. Why? I don't get it. I realize who he reminds me of: Rick Astly. Oh yeah, that's him. Weird voice going with a little body.

Syesha needs to go too. She's beautiful. She has a nice voice. She doesn't stand out.


Here's the order as I see it: 1) David Cook 2) David Archuleta 3) Jason Castro 4) Brooke White 5) Syesha Mercado.

UPDATE: Sister has some good stuff about AI.



I think I'm sick of American Idol again. (But Sister Honeybunch is in love.)